Kevin Baker has a post up detailing how few Britons have guns. Crime skyrocketed when the U.K. brought their gun bans into effect, and the populace wants to… ban more guns. Bonus: Kevin has attracted a Scottish troll (och, wee laddie, I’m-a gonna EAT YOU!) who has an off-the-scale density. One section from the quotes I want to point out:
James Kelly: Thank you for the clarification, Ken. Answer – Because I believe in democracy and the rule of law, rather than ‘might is right’ and imposing one’s will by force.
Unix-Jedi: So sending other people to apply force on your behalf means you’re not imposing your will by force?
James Kelly: Electing a parliament that passes laws, the police and the courts implement those laws…this is pretty basic stuff. I thought belief in democracy and the rule of law was a shared value between our two countries.
Ken: So. If you take A’s property by force, it’s theft. If some guy with a badge claiming to be acting “in the name of the People/King/G-d/Whatever” does it, it’s…what, exactly? Apart from the salutary (sorry for the big word there) benefit of not exposing you to personal danger, that is. The point is, you are perfectly happy imposing your will by someone else’s force. There are several words for that, you know.
Note the interplay– Mr. Kelly believes that if X amount of the population says A, then Y amount must simply roll over and play dead. This belief (I may not do [ACTION], but if I can convince people to vote for [ACTION], not only is it okay, but it is proper) and “group rights” are yin and yang… perfect, matched pairs. I would like to introduce you to a quote from a friend of mine, Major Reid:
“To vote is to wield authority; it is the supreme authority from which all other authority derives — such as mine to make your lives miserable once a day. Force, if you will! — the franchise is force, naked and raw, the Power of the Rods and the Ax. Whether it is exerted by ten men or by ten billion, political authority is force.”
Some of you recognize this quote immediately. You see, Major Reid is the H&MP (History and Moral Philosophy) professor in Starship Troopers. The next section is the part I think is the perfect answer to Mr. Kelly:
“But this universe consists of paired dualities. What is the converse of authority? Mr. Rico.”
He had picked one I could answer. “Responsibility, sir.”
“Applause. Both for practical reasons and for mathematically verifiable moral reasons, authority and responsibility must be equal, else a balancing takes place as surely as current `flows between points of unequal potential. To permit irresponsible authority is to sow disaster; to hold a man responsible for anything he does not control is to behave with blind idiocy. The unlimited democracies were unstable because their citizens were not responsible for the fashion in which they exerted their sovereign authority . . . other than through the tragic logic of history.”
BINGO! “Because I can!” is not– repeat NOT– a valid answer for pulling the lever for anything. Every time you vote, the responsibility for and consequences of your vote rests on you, and you alone. Conversely, it is not– repeat NOT– moral for you to vote to do anything that you cannot do in your own power. However, the most ardent anti-rights advocates always hide in the safety of the masses…
